---
title: Negative Oil & Nickel Squeeze: A Feedback Model for Extreme Commodity Futures Prices
url: https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/arxiv/2610.00951/
site: ML-Quant (https://www.ml-quant.com)
updated: 2026-10-02
license: Summaries CC BY 4.0; links go to the original sources
index: https://www.ml-quant.com/llms.txt
identifier: arXiv:2610.00951
source_url: https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.00951
featured: 2026-10-02
citations: unknown
topic: Derivatives & Volatility
---


# Negative Oil & Nickel Squeeze: A Feedback Model for Extreme Commodity Futures Prices

A feedback model explains extreme commodity futures prices like negative oil by connecting delivery constraints to roll options and long-short position imbalances.

- Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.00951
- Identifier: arXiv:2610.00951
- Released: 2026-10-02
- First featured: Quant Letter No. 133 (2026-10-02): https://www.ml-quant.com/issues/2026-10-02/
- Citations (Semantic Scholar): not tracked
- Published in: not yet
- Topic: Derivatives & Volatility
- Authors: Iosif Zimbidis, Ronnie Sircar

## Abstract (arXiv, CC0)

On April 20, 2020, the May front-month WTI oil futures contract, one day before its expiration date, opened near $\$17/$barrel and dropped far below zero in a single trading day, reaching an intraday low of $-\$40.32$ and settling at $-\$37.63$. Such market behavior was unforeseen at the time. This event, and the March 2022 nickel squeeze, illustrate how constraints on physical delivery create pressure to close futures positions and distort futures prices. We develop a feedback model that connects the resulting price distortion to a roll option, and to the imbalance between delivery-constrained long and short positions. Under lognormal benchmark dynamics, the roll-option value is shown to satisfy a pricing PDE which is nonlinear because its payoff depends on the observed futures price, which itself includes the feedback correction. Remarkably, in both cases, there is an explicit solution in terms of classical Black-Scholes-Margrabe exchange option formulas, up to solving a scalar equation. We show this allows that prices may go negative under distortion of a positive-price lognormal model. An analogous construction applies when the lognormal base is switched to Bachelier normal dynamics. Illustrations based on WTI and nickel show the imbalance required to reproduce the extreme event prices under the benchmark assumptions.

## Related

- [Predicting the volatility of major energy commodity prices: The dynamic persistence model](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/arxiv/2402.01354/): The article proposes a new method for forecasting oil-based volatility that models varying persistence shocks together, improving predictions and surpassing standard models.
- [Surface-Driven Stochastic Volatility for Commodity Options: Identification of Stochastic Vol-of-Vol and Leverage from Smile Dynamics](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/arxiv/2609.27138/): Develops a surface-driven stochastic volatility framework for commodity options using daily volatility surface factors, recovering vol-of-vol and leverage parameters from smile dynamics.
- [How Economic News Drives Implied Volatility in Agricultural Commodity Markets](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/repec/ags-asea26-404810/): Financial and macroeconomic news topics systematically predict implied volatility in corn and soybean markets, with program trading and 2008 crisis topics most robust at short horizons.
- [Adaptive LASSO-MGARCH for Multivariate Volatility Forecasting](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/repec/cdf-wpaper-2026-4/): Introducing coefficient-specific penalization into multivariate GARCH equations reduces complexity and improves out-of-sample covariance forecasts across bonds, equities, and commodities.
- [Commodities Returns and Alternatives](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/ssrn/5276594/): Hilary Till spoke at the Women Investment Professionals organization in Chicago, discussing commodity indices, futures contracts, and hedge funds.
- [Case Studies and Risk Management in Commodity Derivatives Trading: A Presentation](https://www.ml-quant.com/papers/ssrn/5267622/): Hilary Till discussed various risk management aspects at a meeting of the Professional Risk Managers International Association in Chicago.